Wrapped in the curl of a giraffe’s neck in summer, tucked into the nest of a dove in spring, or sleeping against a polar bear cub in winter, the children in Sophia Riley’s surreal, whimsical illustrations are coddled by a gentle menagerie that loves and protects them as a parent would. Riley also includes scenes of children swinging with monkeys, holding hands with penguins, and hammocking with owls, which create a visual atmosphere of peace and play that aptly complements the idealized childhood Schwartz imagines in her time-capsule poem. Against Riley’s rosy-cheeked digital renderings, Schwartz’s nostalgic, yearning poem comes to life.
Though Riley’s illustrations and Schwartz’s doting rhymes are engaging for young readers, This Day I Hold Dear sends a message that seems intended more for the adults in Schwartz’s audience than the children. “When I think of the times that have come and gone,” Schwartz writes, “I take a deep breath and try to hold on.” Though comforting for parents, that sentiment may not hit home for kids, but Schwartz’s final words reach the heart of readers of all ages: “Whatever you dream, I want you to know you are loved from your head to the tip of your toe.”
Takeaway: Wholesome story of parents’ desire to preserve their children’s youth.
Comparable Titles: Patrick McDonnell’s Thank You and Good Night, Emily Winfield Martin’s The Wonderful Things You Will Be.
Production grades
Cover: A
Design and typography: A
Illustrations: A
Editing: A
Marketing copy: A
